Jay's Incredible Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Introducing the menu at Jay's Incredible Pizza reveals a delightful culinary journey that honors the comforting flavors of childhood. Nestled in Wilmington, NC, this gem greets patrons with a warm, carryout-inspired atmosphere, inviting them to experience a slice of nostalgia. The standout dishes include the Pesky Chicken Pizza featuring freshly made basil pesto and a unique over-the-top Pickle Pizza, which has garnered rave reviews from locals.

  • White Pizza: Elevated with extra garlic and cheese, praised for its freshness.
  • Pizzas of the Week: A rotating selection that experiments with adventurous toppings like jalapeno popper.
  • Stuffed Poppers: A perfect accompaniment that complements the pizza offerings.

Every dish showcases quality ingredients, and the attentive service under Jay's management ensures a memorable dining experience. Return visits are a certainty for both locals and travelers alike!